Switch to english versionsprache de grau

My Fight Against Facebook Censorship

5 of 5 (1 Vote)

Facebook suspension

It was 2008. In the German-speaking world, there were once platforms such as StudiVZ, MeinVZ, Wer-Kennt-Wen and the still-existing, but barely used, platform Stayfriends. In a way, these were the early days of social media. Then the Zuckerberg empire entered the scene, and all those troublesome competitors disappeared. A decapitating blow delivered within just a few months.

I, too, joined Facebook relatively early. But, to put it in the words of Robert Habeck, the Green politician so heavily promoted by the media, who has never really been able to relate to Germany, I have never quite known what to make of Facebook. Nevertheless, I am still there – mostly reading or sharing links, and occasionally commenting.

Commenting is a great thing, because you get to hear opinions, views and experiences from all sections of society. Often, they sound very different and far less rosy than the articles published by the press that has been brought into line by the Merkel government. The truth – that has become a real problem for certain political parties. As everyone could see in the last federal election, telling the truth can cost people well-paid positions, pensions and comfortable jobs. These are, of course, extremely important to the many unqualified specialists and university dropouts sitting in the Bundestag and state parliaments. In the private sector, these people would have no chance and would quickly become a burden on the welfare system. That is why criticism from the public, especially criticism expressed on the still freely accessible internet, must of course be nipped in the bud in order to protect the generous rewards for chronic failure and incompetence. But how do you do that in a country where people are officially free to express their opinions? Quite simply: you silence critics and dissenters. We have been there before, so why not bring back a tried-and-tested approach?

That, presumably, was also the thinking of former Justice Minister Heiko Maas, who recently published a 256-page left-wing polemic that immediately landed near the bottom of the sales charts. Shortly before his promotion to foreign minister, a law was therefore hastily passed that was intended to prevent any criticism of the government and its actions. Social networks were threatened with exorbitant fines for publishing so-called “hate speech”. Facebook reacted quickly by setting up a deletion and suspension centre staffed by 500 employees. Afraid of sanctions, Facebook has since been deleting and blocking everything that gets reported, without any proper review. And the left-wing informant is very busy on Facebook, just as in the good old days of the GDR. I, too, have been affected several times. Most deletions and automatic suspensions were reversed after I appealed. Others were not. First I received a one-day suspension, then three days, then five, and finally I was given a four-week ban for a statement that was absolutely correct and did not violate any standards. Well, who cares? I put up with it at first. But when Heiko’s censorship hammer came down again recently, imposing another four-week ban for absolutely no reason, I had had enough.

So what can you do, and what is this all about? Many people simply do not know, because they think Facebook is provided to them for free and that the company can therefore do whatever it likes. Hardly anyone takes the time to read Facebook’s terms and conditions. But that is not how it works. When a Facebook account is opened, both parties enter into a contract. The user receives full access to the platform and, in return, pays with their data. Facebook has now blocked my account again without justification, while continuing to use my data. This action is unlawful. Since Facebook did not respond to my intervention, I felt compelled to hire a law firm to clarify a few matters and put things right. The following demands were made against Facebook:

  1. Payment of the legal fees of €1,500 that I incurred because I had to take this step.
  2. Compensation of €50 for every day the suspension remained in force.
  3. Immediate lifting of the suspension and acknowledgement that it was unlawful.
  4. Resetting the counter of suspensions I had received.
  5. Reinstatement of the post, together with a contractual penalty if the post were deleted again or my account suspended.
  6. Disclosure of which external employees were involved in the suspension.
  7. Disclosure of whether the German federal government was involved in the deletion through information, instructions or suggestions.
  8. A prohibition on using my data while my account was suspended.

Quite a list of demands. But now for the interesting part: how did Facebook respond? At first, Facebook did not respond at all. The formal warning letter was completely ignored. This was to be expected, although it is not necessarily the usual course of events. Since Facebook was not interested in an out-of-court settlement, the only way to pursue my interests was to file a lawsuit. It was filed with the Berlin Regional Court in July 2019. A further three months passed before the court took up the case. During that time – what a coincidence – Facebook suspended me again, this time for 30 days. But once the lawsuit had finally been transferred to Ireland, the Zuckerberg syndicate apparently had no choice but to respond. And so they did: as expected, the law firm White & Case contacted me on Facebook’s behalf, stating that it intended to defend the company.

What followed were the usual exchanges of hostile letters and a court hearing at the Berlin Regional Court at the end of 2020. The hearing was then postponed once more, to May 2021. Two years after the legal dispute had begun. The Regional Court dismissed the claim and delivered a ruling that made no sense at all. Many previous judgments were simply ignored. It was a purely political ruling. No surprise, given Berlin’s political establishment. Since the judgment was, in my view, fundamentally wrong, the case went to the next instance, the Berlin Court of Appeal. In the meantime, the Federal Court of Justice had overturned Facebook’s terms and conditions, on which my suspensions had supposedly been based. This created an entirely new starting point. My law firm tried to reach an agreement with Facebook on the basis of the new situation. However, the company was in no way willing to accept a settlement favourable to me. Curiously, at precisely this time, my Facebook account was hacked and deactivated (not deleted), apparently by pure coincidence. I also had to involve my lawyers to deal with the deactivation, and they managed to get the account reactivated by sending a formal warning. Facebook naturally does not want to reimburse those costs either, and another lawsuit will probably be necessary here as well. In May 2022, the Berlin Court of Appeal overturned the Regional Court’s judgment and upheld the claim in at least one respect: my comment had to be restored without delay, which had, after all, been the main objective:

Lorenz, H. v. Meta Platforms Ireland Ltd.

A fully written and signed judgment is announced by reference to the operative part, which reads as follows:
I. The appeal brought by the claimant against the judgment of the Berlin Regional Court dated 22 April 2021 is upheld, and that judgment is amended.

The defendant is ordered to:

  1. Restore the claimant’s post, reproduced below, which was deleted on 22 April 2019:
    “The poor animals on the farm are at risk of being ritually slaughtered every day. Just imagine the masters of the human race running out of meat while having a barbecue…”
  2. Refrain from suspending the claimant again for posting the item referred to in point 1 on www.facebook.com, or from deleting the post, if this is done in the manner described in the thread concerning the photograph “Migration of Peoples at the Rubbish Hill” published by the claimant on 22 April 2019 (pages 4–12 of the challenged judgment). In the event of non-compliance, the defendant is threatened with a coercive fine of up to €250,000, or, alternatively, coercive detention, or detention for up to six months, to be served by its board members.
  3. Reimburse the claimant for out-of-court legal fees.

Conclusion: Anyone who thinks today that freedom of expression exists in Germany has really failed to hear the warning signs. If you have to fight for three years over a sentence you expressed, only to have a court finally confirm that you did nothing wrong and that the other party acted unlawfully, that should give everyone serious food for thought. Everyone should also think carefully about whether they want to embark on such a legal dispute, because without legal expenses insurance, an average earner can hardly afford it. By now, the costs of the proceedings amount to between €7,000 and €10,000. Had I known that the case would take more than three years, I might have acted differently. Berlin, however, is a very different place to litigate. Since the red-red-green coalition took office in the Senate, all the courts and institutions in the capital have, in my view, been completely overwhelmed. Everyone must decide for themselves how much the right to express an opinion is worth to them. I would not take this route again now, because proceedings here in Berlin simply take too long, and, beyond that, I no longer have much to do with state-controlled media. I nevertheless hope that many other people will continue to take Facebook to court, because that is the only way to counter the deletion frenzy and the suppression of freedom of expression.

 

Add comment

Submit

Found nothing?

Latest Comments