It happened on the A27 on a cold, wet December day in 1989. I was driving towards Bremen in my old Opel Kadett C when it happened: the car began to jerk, slowed down and eventually stopped altogether. Once it had come to a halt on the hard shoulder, my fellow passengers were not exactly thrilled. The event at Bremen’s Schlachthof was due to start in a few hours. What now? My first breakdown with my second car. Of course, there were no mobile phones in the late 1980s, so someone had to walk to one of the nearest emergency telephones and call for roadside assistance. The ADAC arrived fairly quickly. I was not a member at the time, but one good thing about the ADAC still applies today: if you join on the spot, you do not have to pay for the breakdown service. A basic ADAC membership was affordable even for an apprentice. The car was repaired quickly, we continued our journey and still arrived at the event on time.
That was 29 years ago. Since then, I have had dozens more breakdowns and upgraded my membership to include the roadside assistance package, whose cost I almost always recouped within a year. In 90% of cases, I was helped; three times I had to be towed away. In two of those cases, the workshop later found that towing had not been necessary. Each time, it was not the ADAC itself or its mechanics who were responsible, but subcontractors who looked like the ADAC and were ultimately acting only “on its behalf”. They always turned up in a tow truck and were clearly more interested in towing the car away immediately than trying to fix the problem.
The first time one of these subcontractors came to my aid was when my Lancia Y10 broke down in Berlin-Grunewald. The engine suddenly stopped and nothing worked any more. Diagnosis: broken timing chain. The car was towed all the way back to Braunschweig. At the workshop, it turned out that only a cable had come loose. In the second case, I was riding a vintage motorcycle on the A2 towards Berlin when I had to stop somewhere beyond Magdeburg. Once again, a tow truck arrived immediately, and the only help the “mechanic” provided was to pour five litres of petrol into the tank. I even had to pay for that. The motorcycle was towed back to Braunschweig. Here, too, it turned out that the fault was a minor issue that could easily have been fixed on the spot. Apart from these incidents, I was always helped, and I was glad to be able to continue my journey.
Unfortunately, the ADAC’s service and quality deteriorated considerably in the early 2010s. There was soon no longer any financial advantage for members in the other insurance policies offered by the ADAC either. A number of scandals followed, including the manipulation scandal surrounding the “Gelber Engel” award. In addition, other insurers were now offering equivalent services for less money. In 2018, after 29 years of membership, I cancelled my ADAC membership because I had simply decided that I no longer wanted to own a motor vehicle. Good companies have a customer-retention department, especially when someone cancels after almost 30 years. The ADAC could not have cared less. Apparently, the organisation is swimming in money.
Conclusion: I can recommend the ADAC in good conscience, because my experiences with the motoring club were mostly positive. However, this club no longer enjoys the same monopoly it had in the 1980s. Everyone should look into alternatives before taking out an ADAC membership. There are now cheaper and better solutions if all you need is roadside assistance.
Add comment