Switch to english versionsprache de grau

Andy Tours Excursions in the Dominican Republic: Bayahibe and Dominicus

5 of 5 (1 Vote)

Because of the consistently positive reviews on various online portals, I chose Andy Tours for two excursions. I booked day trips to Saona Island for €85 and Catalina Island for €95. Those prices raised eyebrows as soon as I paid. Almost €100 for a day trip is hardly a bargain, after all. Expectations were correspondingly high. The first trip was to Saona Island, the largest offshore island of the Dominican Republic. The tour operator's website states:

“Pick-up at your hotel takes place between 8:00 and 8:15 a.m.”

That statement was not entirely accurate. There was no hotel pick-up. Since the office was nearby, however, this was not a problem. The rest of the process was less understandable. Although many participants had already paid, all bookings first had to be checked again. Cash customers were charged individually, online payments were verified, and every guest was ticked off on lists. This took an unnecessarily long time. I could not understand why guests who had already paid were asked to arrive so early, only to wait for an antiquated accounting system.

According to the operator, the bus ride to Bayahibe takes about five minutes. That estimate also proved rather optimistic: the journey actually took around fifteen minutes. The same procedure began all over again there. More tour groups arrived, names were checked and lists processed, while everyone else stood in the blazing sun for around thirty minutes. Once all participants had assembled, the next surprise followed. Andy Tours advertises “German-speaking guides only and limited-size groups” on its website. The German-speaking guide was indeed there. But there was nothing small about the group. Around fifty people squeezed onto the boat. One inevitably wondered what the operator considers “limited”. Perhaps not five hundred people. Even so, the advertising promise already felt rather misleading at the outset.

The speedboat was hardly a source of enthusiasm either. There was visible damage to the stern, and the passengers sat packed together like sardines in a tin. As soon as the boat left the harbour, loud music began, at a volume that came close to physical assault. There is nothing wrong with a lively atmosphere in principle. But when you are exposed to this kind of continuous noise for a long time, eventually there is no way to escape it. There was apparently no consideration for guests who would rather enjoy the scenery or the sea. The first stop was in Parque Nacional del Este. The guide's information was limited to a few sentences before the journey continued. Next came the snorkelling stop at the “Piscina Natural”. The water was pleasant, but because the boat was completely full, even putting on the snorkelling gear became a challenge. There was practically no room to move. Before the next stop, the guide gave a few explanations about the local wildlife. However, everything was presented in the typical entertainment-host style and regularly accompanied by loud “Wow!” and “Ooooh!” reactions from the group. Tastes differ, of course, but this kind of entertainment was more reminiscent of a party excursion to the Ballermann than a nature tour.

The subsequent stop at Canto de la Playa was one of the more pleasant parts of the day. At last there was enough room to get into the water without jostling and enjoy the surroundings a little. The operator's website describes this beach as one of the island's most beautiful, which “not every tour operator visits because it is too far away”. That is quite a claim, since several excursion boats were in the bay during our stay. The place did not seem so exclusive after all. The view along the beach was even more sobering. Considerable amounts of plastic waste had accumulated in places among the palm trees and turquoise water—something understandably absent from the operator's promotional photos. The promise that we would be able to explore the offshore coral banks was equally questionable. In reality, the coral begins only where the surf breaks on the outer reef. There is practically no coral in the shallow area near the shore. The website description therefore raised expectations that were not met on site. The next stretch of beach had no name, but offered the most beautiful setting of the entire day. The water shimmered in vivid shades of turquoise and the fine sandy beach really invited you to swim. However, word of its beauty had clearly got around. Numerous boats were anchored in the bay and the beach was correspondingly crowded. It was hardly a deserted South Pacific paradise. Lunch, on the other hand, was a pleasant surprise. The food was tasty, plentiful and of considerably better quality than expected.

A catamaran was waiting for the return journey. At last, plenty of room—or so one might have thought. Shortly before departure, another tour group boarded, and the boat quickly became crowded again. The predominantly South American guests were already in a party mood, which raised the noise level even further. According to the operator, guests could “help themselves to their heart's content—everything included” on board. In the end, the selection consisted of water, Coke, Sprite and rum. That seemed rather limited for an excursion advertised as a VIP tour. One could not help wondering what a regular tour would offer. Shortly before reaching the departure harbour, passengers were also asked for tips. On the catamaran, that seemed quite justified: the crew was friendly and committed, and even handed out small bandanas as souvenirs when saying goodbye. The organisation at the end, however, was less convincing. There was complete confusion at the harbour. Most buses had already left while some participants were still waiting, unsure how they would get back. In the end, everyone did reach their hotel. In my case, however, the ride ended somewhere on a road in Dominicus. Fortunately, my accommodation was only a few minutes' walk away. The return transfer “right to the hotel” advertised on the website did not happen.

After the experience on Saona, it is understandable that my enthusiasm for the second excursion was limited. If the Catalina trip had not already been scheduled in advance, I probably would not have booked another one. Nevertheless, every provider deserves a second chance. The morning arrangements initially differed little from the Saona trip. Once again, the paperwork took a great deal of time. Almost an hour and a half passed before all participants had been registered and the boat finally left the harbour. The website had advertised a “large, comfortable double-decker motor catamaran”. However, there was no catamaran at the pier. Instead, a spacious motorboat was used. In the end, that was no disadvantage. Unlike the Saona trip, there was enough room this time, making the crossing to the island much more relaxed. Catalina was reached after around 45 minutes. Soft drinks, beer and rum were served during the journey, along with small snacks. The first stop was at an offshore coral reef that was well suited to snorkelling. Although this reef was not one of the Caribbean's most spectacular diving or snorkelling sites, the stop was still worthwhile. The few larger schools of fish owed their presence less to nature than to the fish food that had been scattered beforehand—a popular trick used by many excursion operators to show guests as many marine creatures as possible. The real highlight of the tour came next: the Casa de Campo beach area on Catalina. According to Andy Tours, this is an exclusive area visited on day trips only by this operator. Apparently, celebrities such as Ben Affleck and Vin Diesel regularly rent private sections of the beach here.

The place did not seem quite so exclusive, though. Numerous other boats were anchored in the bay, inevitably raising the question of whether Andy Tours really is the only operator with access to this beach. At least one of the operator's claims proved true: there were no hawkers or pushy souvenir sellers. That made for a much more pleasant atmosphere than at many other beaches in the Dominican Republic. A small all-inclusive bar and a lunch buffet awaited guests on the beach. The selection was decent, the quality was convincing, and there was plenty of time to explore the island independently or simply relax in the turquoise water. Unlike the Saona trip, the entire excursion felt much more relaxed. There was little crowding and the atmosphere was considerably more pleasant overall. In the afternoon we returned to Bayahibe. As on the outward journey, music was played on board at a volume that will not appeal to everyone. Anyone looking for entertainment and a party atmosphere will probably enjoy it.

Back at the harbour, the organisation was pleasantly smooth this time. The buses were ready and the transfer to Dominicus also worked without any significant delays. Both excursions offered scenic destinations and an overall good impression of two of the Dominican Republic's best-known islands. Nevertheless, they left very different overall impressions. The Saona trip suffered above all from organisational shortcomings. Long waiting times, overcrowded boats and several advertising promises that were only partly borne out on site noticeably detracted from the experience. The constant entertainment programme was another factor and, in my view, entirely unnecessary. The Catalina trip, by contrast, was much better organised. The boat was less crowded, the stops felt more relaxed, and the beach area offered greater recreational value. Although some of the operator's claims were also interpreted rather generously here, the excursion was considerably more enjoyable overall. The biggest criticism remains the price. At €85 and €95 per person, the trips should have come closer to the operator's grand promises. In the end, the excursions advertised as VIP tours offered little that clearly distinguished them from cheaper trips run by local operators. Travellers who place particular value on a German-speaking guide and do not mind entertainment programmes and larger groups will probably be satisfied with Andy Tours. Those who prefer smaller groups, more peace and quiet, and better value for money should certainly take a look at the offers from local operators.

Vielleicht auch Interessant:

 

 

Add comment

Submit

Found nothing?

Latest Comments