Groundhog Day every week. Every week, in the form of a newsletter from Mr Gerd Appenzeller. In it, Mr Appenzeller even greets me personally. Mr Appenzeller of the Tagesspiegel has made it his task to keep the people of Reinickendorf up to date. Born in 1943, Mr Appenzeller should really have been retired long ago. Whether a meagre pension or boredom is what keeps him glued to his editor’s chair is another matter. Admittedly, his newsletter is often very interesting, and I enjoy reading it. But his most recent circular from Hermsdorf was a little irritating. In it, he criticised private blogs which, in his opinion, spread so-called fake news. What this nice older gentleman had to say deserves a closer look.
In practically every Berlin district there are blogs where people use the internet to exchange information and discuss everyday matters. You see photographs of beautiful landscapes, read the Wanted/Found section to find out what someone has to sell or give away, or what someone else needs. Events ranging from kindergarten bazaars to flea markets are announced. The blogs are really good neighbourhood portals.
Quite right! However, things such as Wanted/Found have little to do with a traditional blog. Facebook pages run by interest groups are not blogs either, nor are neighbourhood portals of one kind or another.
But for several months now I have sensed a change in the subject matter and tone of some of them. Some posts are becoming more polemical, and the vocabulary suggests that their authors are close to the AfD. That is not my style, but it has to be accepted as part of democratic debate.
Interesting that this is finally being noticed after all these years: the mood in this country is not particularly good. Some people simply take a little longer to catch on. What is alarming, however, is the suggestion that anyone who does not share the writer’s opinion is a potential AfD sympathiser. Shouldn’t journalists be neutral? The author’s political leanings are obvious here.
It becomes problematic when claims and labels appear for which there is no evidence. Anyone who does not look “German” is a “Merkel man”, meaning a refugee or asylum seeker. Future residents of an accommodation centre in Märkisches Viertel are “Merkel guests”. A young man caught red-handed by the police is labelled with the insinuation that you can tell where he comes from. When people argue against such sweeping judgements, those other opinions quickly disappear…
On the one hand, the writer complains about the alleged prejudice some people show towards those who look different; on the other, he thinks it is perfectly acceptable to suggest that people whose opinions differ from his own are close to the AfD.
And there are repeated suspicions about crimes that the press, for mysterious reasons, does not report.
People have not failed to notice over the past three years that the press and media still conceal or downplay many things because the government wants them to. And fake news can also be found in the so-called quality media. That is why more and more people turn to alternative media such as blogs, which now seem more trustworthy. This is particularly true when it comes to crime or politics.
I realised that, as a journalist, I should not merely read this but urgently respond to it when I saw this user comment: “Just for your information: the kiosk on Titiseestraße was robbed yesterday evening… and shortly afterwards, apparently, the Hem petrol station on Zabel-Krüger-Damm as well… also strange that there isn’t a single line about it anywhere.”
For a journalist at a rather insignificant Berlin newspaper – albeit one with a substantial circulation – this is obviously a major problem. Amateurs are faster. The explanation is simple:
I paused. Yes, why had nothing been reported? Was it too late for the editorial deadline? I checked the police report. There was nothing there either. Strange. I called the police press office and learned that not every serious crime appears in the police report – there are simply too many, including robberies. […] My enquiries confirmed that the kiosk on Titiseestraße really had been robbed. Of course, the police had a report about it; it simply had not been published […]
So the Tagesspiegel relies exclusively on police reports. Interesting way of working. Well, everyone knows who the police are subordinate to. Everyone also knows that all police reports are filtered, just the way the government likes them. On top of that, the department is in complete disarray.
The police know nothing about a robbery at a petrol station. Neither at the station on Zabel-Krüger-Damm, nor at another Hem station on Berliner Straße, nor at a third one. One can assume it never happened, because it is unlikely that petrol station staff who had been robbed would not call the police.
Oh, I see. If the police know nothing about it, nothing can have happened.
Without wishing to express distrust of the police press office (I have no reason to do so), I find it unsatisfactory that the police press office makes a preliminary selection for me of what might be worth reporting.
How about doing some reporting of your own? Find sources, ask questions, keep pushing. Did you actually ask all the petrol stations around Zabel-Krüger-Damm yourself? Probably not. It is simply easier to take a police report, present it as the truth, and then denounce all other reports as fake news. That is journalism in 2018.
If you hear about serious crimes yourself, please send me an email – I will try to clarify the facts with the help of the police press office, and I will report on them.
Unbelievable. Now the public is supposed to do the journalists’ work for them, instead of journalists making an effort to investigate for themselves. Working with the police means working with the state, especially with its press office. That is not what independent, free journalism looks like.
And if you are active in one of the district’s blogs yourself, please think beforehand about whether you should forward a rumour – something you can discuss harmlessly with friends around a regulars’ table – to a mailing list of well over 1,000 recipients.
Here, blogs are disparaged as nothing more than stupid pub talk. A journalist is asking the public to do his job for him. No wonder newspapers are on the brink. This example makes it quite clear that a daily newspaper is nothing more than a mouthpiece for the government. Copy and paste from the police press office – and this is admitted openly and without embarrassment.
This is a clear admission of journalistic bankruptcy. Any journalist who has to beg the public for information because he apparently does not see himself capable of obtaining it should quickly consider hanging up his boots. Passing off someone else’s work as your own under the guise of “I’ll take care of it for you” is highly questionable.
Update 25 July 23018: Mr Appenzeller’s latest newsletter obviously did not go down well with all readers. Today, a new newsletter was sent out. In it, Mr Appenzeller reacted rather thin-skinnedly to certain responses to his previous pamphlet. He once again complained about allegedly AfD-friendly posts on this site and this time even revealed the platform’s name. Mr Appenzeller seems to have a real problem with the AfD. He makes it sound as though this party had staged a coup and forced its way into the Bundestag last year. But on this point, Mr Appenzeller is hardly alone and is in very good company. The Facebook group, of which Mr Appenzeller was also a member, kicked him out along with several other members. Quite rightly. And once again Mr Appenzeller complains about fake news. Among other things, the platform announced:
Dear members, unfortunately we had to realise that there were a few moles in this group who passed on content and information from the group to outsiders and presented it in a completely distorted way (that we are all Nazis, a brown swamp, advocates of völkisch ideology, deliberately spreading fake news, hate mail and inflammatory posts).
Mr Appenzeller responded:
This was about the “Mein Reinickendorf” group. I did not accuse its members of being Nazis or a brown swamp. But making such a claim – that, too, is part of the whole fake-news strategy…
On this point, Mr Appenzeller is right. He did not directly accuse anyone of that in his newsletter. But the group’s response does not accuse him personally of having made that exact statement either. We shall see whether the Reinickendorf fake-news saga enters another round.
Source: Tagesspiegel
Author: Gerd Appenzeller

Add comment