Switch to english versionsprache de grau

    When the Smart Turns into a Nightmare

    3.7 of 5 (3 Votes)

    Smart Cabrio TDI

    At 12 years old, a car is no longer exactly new. Still, until then I had had very little trouble with my Smart Cabrio TDI. It had also passed its most recent roadworthiness test without any defects, and the repairs up to that point could essentially be put down to normal wear and tear. Then came the strange day when I pulled up at a petrol pump, switched off the engine and took the ignition key out – but the engine continued running for a few more seconds. Meanwhile, all the warning lights on the dashboard lit up. The problem did not occur again for weeks, so I initially ignored the Smart’s odd behaviour. But then it happened again: ignition off, engine still running. Only when I activated the central locking did the engine switch off. The next morning, the Smart was completely dead. Not even the doors would open. I had to crawl in through the boot just to open a door. The ADAC jump-started the car, and everything worked normally again. But a day later, nothing worked at all. After another jump-start, I took the car to a garage. The mechanics checked the electrical system and read the fault memory. They thought they had found the problem and sent my Smart home, supposedly repaired, for a hefty 160 euros. In fact, it ran without problems for two days. Then the same thing happened again: the battery had discharged overnight. The power drain while parked had not been fixed. That was a poor showing from the garage I had trusted, which had clearly not made much effort to solve the problem. The difficulties became increasingly serious. Previously, I had always been able to continue driving after a jump-start, but now I could not even engage a gear. With great difficulty, I managed to reach a garage – this time the one I trust (I had gone to the other one because my usual garage was on holiday). Even my trusted mechanics initially could not work out why the Smart’s ignition stayed on and drained the battery. After two weeks without a car, I was finally able to collect my beloved Smart. But even as I picked it up, I felt sceptical. After all that trouble, was everything really supposed to be fine now? A faulty gear selector was said to be the solution to the mystery. To be on the safe side, they also fitted a new battery, as the repeated problems were likely to have reduced the battery’s capacity. And so the car from Daimler was back on the road. Yet I still had an uneasy feeling whenever I got in. Unfortunately, that feeling proved justified. After a few days when everything had worked perfectly, the same thing happened again. When I switched off the engine, all the warning lights started flashing. Instead of the mileage, the display suddenly showed only a minus sign. It took several turns of the ignition key before the warning lights went out. The fault had clearly not been fixed. At least the car still starts, perhaps because the battery is new and can simply last longer. For the past two days, the warning lights have stopped flashing when the engine is switched off. The Smart still starts – but the question is probably how much longer it will do so. A return to the garage is unavoidable, although whether anyone will be able to fix the problem remains to be seen.

    Update: After three weeks, the fault was finally found. The control unit was refurbished, as was the relay strip beneath the seat. Moisture had apparently caused considerable damage there. The Smart has now been driving without any further problems for three months. Anyone experiencing similar problems should investigate this area.

    Defekte Mittelschaltung Smart TDI Cabrio

    Image: A faulty gear selector – unfortunately, it was not the cause of the problem.

    Comments

    0
    Steffan
    8 years ago
    I’m having the same problem. What exactly was the issue in your case?
    Like Like Quote
    0
    Karsten
    8 years ago
    Do you happen to remember exactly what it was within the control box, or which relay is acting up? I’m currently having the exact same problem. Could you please drop me a line at:
    Like Like Quote

    Add comment

    Submit

    Found nothing?

    Latest Comments

    Kenya

    Nature, Wildlife and Beaches

    The African continent consists of many countries with a wide variety of cultures and fascinating flora and fauna. However, not all countries are as easy to explore as a tourist destination as Kenya.

    Goslar

    Where the World Is Still in Order

    Anyone who grew up in the Braunschweig region is probably familiar with the area around the medieval town of Goslar. During the days of East Germany, the western Harz Mountains, rising just behind the Imperial Palace town, were always a popular destination. After German reunification, tourism declined but is now slowly picking up again.

    Mauritius

    Island of Many Disappointments

    The first thing that comes to mind when people hear about the island of Mauritius is miles of white sandy beaches, palm trees and exotic wildlife. Some of these things are indeed true, but many things are actually quite different. Above all, Mauritius is still one thing: Africa.

    Activities

    • Devils Town

      Serbia’s cities may still seem a little grey and post-communist, but that changes as soon as you leave the city limits and reach the countryside. There you will find completely untouched, undeveloped and fascinating nature.

    • Lake Naivasha

      When it comes to wildlife, count me in. Far from the hustle and bustle of the coast, there is a beautiful lake. In the middle of nowhere, marabou storks, pelicans, ibises and, of course, hippos roam.

    • Kurische Nehrung

      The peninsula, almost 100 kilometres long, is shared by Russia and Lithuania. Some things are reminiscent of a North Sea island, while others recall the German past of this Baltic Sea archipelago.

    • Shimba Hills

      It cannot be compared with one of the many national parks, but the Shimba Hills nature reserve still has plenty to offer.

    • The Invalids’ Cemetery

      The Invalids’ Cemetery

      The Invalids’ Cemetery in Berlin is located in the middle of the city, alongside the former Wall Trail. Most people walking through it have no idea that they are passing the grave of one of history’s greatest war criminals.

    • Brooklyn Brewery

      Brooklyn Brewery in Williamsburg is one of the 4,000 active breweries in the United States. The company offers a good brewery tour, although it focuses a little too much on getting visitors to spend money.

      Cuba

      Karibischer Kommunismus.

      Not much has changed on the island of Cuba since the 1960s. Progress is only gradual. At least by the late 2010s, internet access was available, even if only for limited periods.

      Dominican Republic

      The Caribbean dream.

      The Dominican Republic does not have the best reputation. It is often seen as a party destination and a playground for older, wealthy white men. But the Samaná Peninsula does not live up to that stereotype.

      Russia

      The ultimate adventure holiday.

      Even today, many people still do not consider Russia a worthwhile travel destination. I took the plunge and immersed myself in a wonderful world full of great people.

      City breaks

      • New York City

        With a bit of luck, I managed to catch a direct flight from Berlin to New York City just in time — shortly afterwards, Air Berlin went bankrupt. The city reminds you of a film at every turn. It is well worth a visit.

      • Riga/Kuldiga

        The Baltic country has long since ceased to be an insider tip. However, tourism is concentrated almost entirely on Riga. The really interesting places are to be found beyond Latvia’s major cities.

      • Prague

        For 30 years now, Prague has experienced an uninterrupted influx of tourists from all over the world. If you choose the right time of year, however, the city can be explored at a very relaxed pace.

      • Bucharest

        Bucharest is the European Union’s seventh-largest city. Located in southern Romania, it stands out for its post-communist architecture and still-affordable cost of living.

      • Niš

        Niš

        The city of Niš lies in southern Serbia, roughly between Sofia and Kosovo. Although most people have never heard of it, the surrounding area has a great deal to offer.

      • Kraków

        Kraków is one of Poland’s most interesting cities. Far to the east, it has a great deal of history to offer. Follow in the footsteps of Oskar Schindler.